FACT CHECK: Did âThousandsâ Of âFar-Right Extremistsâ Attend The Richmond Pro-Gun Rally?
HuffPost published an article with a headline claiming âthousandsâ of âfar-right extremistsâ attended a Jan. 20 gun-rights rally in Richmond, Virginia.
âThousands Of Pro-Gun Activists And Far-Right Extremists Swarm Richmond, Virginia,â reads the headline.
Verdict: False
While some nationalist groups did attend the Richmond gun-rights rally, thereâs no evidence âthousandsâ of âfar-right extremistsâ were there. Experts and journalists gave the Daily Caller News Foundation lower estimates.
Fact Check:
The Virginia Division of Capitol Police estimated 22,000 people attended the Jan. 20 gun-rights rally in Richmond to protest various recent gun control proposals. Some officials feared violence might occur at the rally, particularly after the FBI announced days before that it had arrested three alleged members of white supremacist group The Base. But, despite these concerns, the rally remained peaceful, with only one reported arrest, according to The Washington Post.
âThousands Of Pro-Gun Activists And Far-Right Extremists Swarm Richmond, Virginia,â read HuffPostâs headline for a Jan. 20 article on the rally. (RELATED: Article Claims Trump Will Sign An Executive Order Creating Term Limits For Congress)
To support the claim, the HuffPost author pointed to the presence of groups such as the Proud Boys, Oath Keepers and American Guard, as well as other unnamed âfar-right militants, conspiracy theorists.â Pictures and videos from the rally confirm that members of those groups were, in fact, in attendance.
The Southern Poverty Law Center (SPLC), a legal advocacy group, has designated the Oath Keepers and Proud Boys as âextremistsâ and the American Guard as a âhate group,â while the Anti-Defamation League (ADL), a Jewish nonprofit organization, characterizes all three groups as âextremists.â
Experts agreed some far-right extremists likely did attend the Richmond gun-rights rally but disputed HuffPostâs âthousandsâ number.
âItâs reasonable to assume that some far right extremists attended the event insofar as gun ownership rights loom large in their worldview,â explained George Michael, a professor of criminal justice at Westfield State University and author of âConfronting Right Wing Extremism and Terrorism in the USA,â in an email to the DCNF. âHowever, I didnât see evidence of far-right involvement on an organizational level.â
âIâve seen nothing to suggest that there were thousands of far-right extremists in attendance,â said Darren Mulloy, a Wilfrid Laurier University history professor and author of âEnemies of the State: The Radical Right in American from FDR to Trump,â in an email to the DCNF.
Laird Wilcox, co-author of âAmerican Extremists Militias, Supremacists, Klansmen, Communists & Others,â also told the DCNF he did not see evidence that âthousandsâ of âfar right extremistsâ attended the rally.
âIt was mostly single-issue people concerned about the Second Amendment. Most of those people were middle to moderate-right conservatives,â he said. âThey were not âfar-right extremists.ââ
Only one journalist that the DCNF talked to speculated the number could be high, but he took pains to make clear his number was an estimate.
âI would say less than, but somewhere hovering around 20% of the folks at the rally likely met this qualification,â said Robert Evans, a Bellingcat investigative reporter present at the gun-rights rally. âIâd say I personally saw somewhere around a dozen [Right Wing Death Squad] patches, in addition to âhelicopterâ shirts and imagery (references to how the Pinochet regime executed left-wing dissidents). I also saw hundreds and hundreds of references to the âboogaloo,â the idea of an inevitable coming second civil war.â
Townhall reporter Julio Rosas told the DCNF that âvery fewâ members of the aforementioned groups were there, while New2Share editor-in-chief Ford Fischer estimated âin the hundreds.â
But individuals wearing such imagery arenât necessarily âfar-right extremists.â On its website, the ADL notes that âgamers and history buffsâ make references to âboogaloo.â Some individuals âstill use the phrase as a joke,â according to the ADL.
Even if all such people were considered far-right extremists, there is no definitive way to determine the exact ratio of far-right extremists to gun advocates and other attendees at the rally. Social media only turned up anecdotal instances of such imagery.
Neither the National Consortium for the Study of Terrorism and Responses to Terrorism nor the Counter Extremism Project, organizations that extensively study and track U.S. extremism, had information about who or what groups attended the rally.
âThis was different from [Charlottesville, Virginia] in many ways in that there hardened bigots and violent extremists were key to the organizing of the event,â Center for the Study of Hate and Extremism Director Brian Levin told the DCNF in an email. âRichmondâs had been going on for years and was not organized by bigots. That being said, outside extremists made a very big deal about the Richmond event online.â
No other policy organizations could corroborate HuffPostâs claim, and the DCNF found no evidence that âthousandsâ of âfar-right extremistsâ attended the rally. We rate this headline false.
Trevor Schakohl and Elias Atienza contributed to this report.