FACT CHECK: Did Victoria Premier Daniel Andrews Say, âInsisting On Human Rights Is Not Only Selfish, Itâs Stupidâ?
An Instagram post claims Daniel Andrews, the premier of Australiaâs Victoria state, once said, âInsisting on human rights is not only selfish, itâs stupid.â
View this post on Instagram
Nothing should stand above human rights. Nothing! #covid19 #coronavirus #melbournelockdown
A post shared by Matt Lawson Photography (@mattlawsonphotography) on Sep 16, 2020 at 7:31am PDT
Verdict: False
There is no record of Andrews making the statement in the post. It appears be a hyperbolic embellishment from a satire article based on an actual quote Andrews said.
Fact Check:
Andrews, the leader of the Australian state of Victoriaâs government, instituted measures meant to help curb the spread of coronavirus effective 11:59 p.m. local time Sept. 13, including issuing a curfew of 9 p.m. and restricting travel to essential purposes, per Victoriaâs Health and Human Services website. Some Victorian citizens have protested these restrictions, and Federal Liberal MP Tim Wilson has reportedly asked for an investigation to see if the restrictions violate human rights, according to SBS News.
An image shared on Instagram claims Andrews has openly disparaged those protesting the restrictions, saying, âIn fact, youâd be surprised at how much can be avoided if people stop insisting on their personal freedoms. Because insisting on human rights is not only selfish, itâs stupid.â (RELATED: Did Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison Tweet, âIâm So Glad We Donât Have Any Racism Here In Australiaâ?)
While Andrews has defended the coronavirus mitigation measures, the Daily Caller News Foundation could not find any evidence to corroborate that he said the quote attributed to him in the Instagram post. A search of Andrewsâ verified Twitter account, @DanielAndrewsMP, turned up no instances of him making the remark. Had the state leader make the comment, it likely would have been reported on by Australian media outlets, but none have done so. A Victorian government spokesperson confirmed to the Australian Associated Press that Andrews never made the alleged comment.
The misattributed quote appears to originate from a Sept. 15 satire article published by The Spectator Australia that appeared to poke fun at Andrewsâ stance on Victoriaâs coronavirus restrictions. While the Spectator article includes a clear disclaimer that reads, âDrongo alert: what follows is satire,â the Instagram post does not include such a warning, presenting the quote as factual.
The fabricated quote from the satire article appears to be a hyperbolic embellishment of one of the state leaderâs actual quotes. During a Sept. 13 press conference, Andrews said, âProtesting is not only selfish, but itâs stupid.â
Andrewsâ office did not return a request for comment.
UPDATE: This article has been updated to add the factual quote that the hyperbolic embellishment was based on.